Basics of Point and Figure Charting

 

Introduction

The point and figure chart is the only method of charting, which was originated by traders, and is probably the oldest western method of charting prices around. The roots of the point and figure method date way back into trading lore, as it has been intimated that this method was successfully used by the legendary trader James R. Keene during the merger of US Steel in 1901. Mr. Keene was employed by Andrew Carnegie to distribute, as Carnegie refused to take stock as payment for his equity interest in the company. According to lore, Keene, using point and figure charting and tape reading, managed to promote the stock and get rid of Carnegies sizeable stake with out causing the price to crash. This simple method of charting has stood the test of time and requires less time to construct and maintain than the traditional "bar chart".

The Point and Figure Method derives its name from the fact that price is recorded using figures (X's and O's) to represent point….hence Point and Figure. Charles Dow, the original founder of the Wall Street Journal and the inventor of Stock Indexes, was rumored to be a point and figure user, and from personal experience the practice of Point and Figure charting is alive and well today on the floor of the Chicago Board of Trade. It is the methods simplicity in identifying price trends, support and resistance, and its ease of upkeep that has allowed this method to endure the test of time, even in the age of web pages, personal computers, and the information explosion.

Differences Between Bar Charts and Point and Figure Charts

Bar charts are two-dimensional charts, constructed with horizontal axis representing time and the vertical axis-representing price. The point and figure method is one dimensional, with only the vertical axis labeled, and it represents price and only price.

Bar charts use a basic measure of time as the representation of price, with one bar representing a pre determined unit (5 minutes, 1 day, 1 week, 1 month, etc.). The Point and Figure Method records price swings, not price versus time. As such, this method of charting allows the trader to encapsulate in one simple method the true concern for speculators- Price and probable price direction!

The Point and Figure Method also requires less upkeep than traditional charts, as the Point and Figure Method helps to "filter out" noise on the charts by only concerning itself with movements of a significant size. Unlike the traditional bar chart, which requires an update according to the calendar (daily, weekly or monthly), the Point and Figure chart only requires an update when justified by price.

Pattern Recognition is also simpler, and less subject to emotion using the Point and Figure Method. Common bar chart patterns, like the "Head and Shoulders" pattern require subjectivity, while Point and Figure patterns can be more easily identified, as only price swings are measured, not calendar movement as well as price. Because this method was developed by speculators, for use in speculation, this is the only method of charting which was developed entirely for speculation, and used strictly by speculators. As such, this method has not been borrowed from another field, or some new fangeled idea developed to generate book sales or commissions, but a time honored tradition in speculation.

Constructing and Using a Point and Figure Chart

Construction of a Point and Figure chart is very simple. Up movements of a certain magnitude are designated by an X on the chart, while down movements of a comparable magnitude are recorded by a series of O on a chart. In constructing Point and Figure Charts, Grainguide recommends using the 3 Box Reversal Method.

The first concept to understand is the BOX SIZE. The Box Size is the amount of price movement required to completely fill a Box or grid on the chart. For example, if charting Wheat, we would use a Box Size of 5 cents. Using this method, price swings less than 15 cents (three 5 cent boxes) in either direction are ignored, deemed irrelevant to the intermediate trader or hedger in deciding the trend of the market.

The next concept is Reversal. Assume the price of Wheat has rallied 15 cents from a previous low point, which would be signified by a column of 3 X's: (prices went from a low of 245 to a high of 260)

 

270
265
260 X
255 X
250 X
245

 

Each additional 5 cent move to the upside would be recorded by an additional X on the above chart. Assuming over the next several sessions, prices managed to rally above the 265 level, a new X would be added to the column:

 

270
265 X
260 X
255 X
250 X
245

However, if after prices crossed above the 265 level, the price of a specific Wheat contract broke -15 cents, then a new column of O's would be added to the chart, as prices have corrected a significant amount: (price broke from a high of 267 to a low of 249 3/4, as the 267 high is not high enough to plot another X at 270, while a break through 250 to 249 3/4 is significant enough to fill 3 5 cent boxes at 260, 255, and 250):

270
265

X

260

X

O
255

X

O
250

X

O
245

Following the recording of O on the chart at 250, the daily low is checked each day. If the daily low is less than 245, then another O would be recorded on the chart in the same column. However, if the daily low is greater than the next lower Box, the daily high is then checked to see if it is greater than the price 3 boxes higher (or 265 in this example). If the daily low is greater than 245 and the daily high is less than 265, then no notation is made on the chart. Whenever one is currently in a column of O's, the daily low is checked first for the update, and when a new notation is made, you are done for the day. However, if a new notation is not necessary to the downside, then the daily high is checked to see if a reversal notation can be made. The opposite rules apply when in a column of X's, with the daily high checked first, then if no notation is required, the daily low is checked. Once a new notation is made, all further price movement is ignored until the following day.

To continue our example, we have made a notation at 250, when prices touched 249 3/4. If the price of Wheat stays above 245 for the next several sessions, and after 6 days, the following daily prices are recorded:

 

Open

High

Low

Close

257

265 1/2

256 3/4

263

Our first step is to identify whether we are in a column of X's or O's. Our last chart notation was made at 250, in a column of O's. Because we are in a column of O's, we check the daily low to see if it is below 245. Given that 256 3/4 is greater than 245, we then check the daily high. If the daily high is greater than 3 boxes above our column low of 250, or (250 + (3*5))=265, then we switch to the next column and add a series of X's. Because 265 1/2 is greater than 265, we add 3 X's to our chart in the next column to the right as follows:

Before After
270 270
265 X 265 X X
260 X O 260 X O X
255 X O 255 X O X
250 X O 250 X O
245 245

This process is continued each day, and the chart evolves into a series of 15 cent or greater moves in the price of Wheat:

310 X
305 X O X
300 X O X O
295 X O X O
290 X O O
285 X X O
280 X O X O
275 X O X O X
270 X O O X O
265 X X X O X O
260 X O X O X O O
255 X O X O X O
250 X O O
245
240

The true beauty of the Point and Figure Method lies in how well it identifies trends. The following are the basic definitions of a bull and bear trend:

Bull Trend: An upward trend in prices is defined as a series of HIGHER HIGHS and HIGHER LOWS

Bear Trend: A downward trend in prices is defined as a series of LOWER LOWS and LOWER HIGHS

Re-examining the POINT and FIGURE chart above the start of BULL Trend and a BEAR Trend can clearly be seen:

310 X
305 X O X
300 X O X O
295 X O X O Bearish Trend Starts
290 X O O
285 X X O
280 X O X O
275 X O X O X
270

Bullish Trend Starts-

X O O X O
265 X X X O X O
260 X O X O X O O
255 X O X O X O
250 X O O
245
240

Using the Point and Figure Method, the Trend can easily be identified. When the price of Wheat broke through 270 to the upside, a Bull Market began. This Bull Market would be considered into effect until prices broke through support at 250. After prices traded from 270 up to 285, they corrected back down to 270. The next rally carried prices up to 310, but when prices penetrated 285, the second time, the conservative trader could move his stop loss to 265, dramatically reducing his/her risk. This rally continued up to 310, then corrected back to 290. The next rally halted at 305, making a lower high! Conservative traders could move their stop loss to 285, while aggressive traders would have moved the stop loss to 290.

When prices penetrated 285 to the downside, a bearish trend had begun. This can easily be seen on the Point and Figure Chart as a lower HIGH (at 305) followed by a lower LOW (285 vs the previous low at 290). The initiation of the Bearish Trend at 285 may get traders to short this market at 285, with a predetermined stop loss at 305.

Choosing Box Sizes

One of the major benefits to the point and figure method is that it portrays only the price swings, which the practitioner tells it too. If the box size is too small, then the Point and Figure Chart will not filter out the noise, while too large a filter will not present enough detail in the chart to make it useful.

Because the Grain markets have maximum tradeable daily limits, these are the filter or Box Size we feel are the most appropriate for the Grain markets, long term. The Long Term trend Charts are ideal patient traders, who are comfortable taking more risk for higher rewards. The larger box sizes identify the long term trend of the market.

We have found that half of the daily is a good measure of the intermediate trend of the grain markets. This is ideal for picking bottoms and tops in the grain markets, especially when they are in overvalued or undervalued zones. This is the trend that Grainguide generally trades, which is an intermediate trend, which is the shortest trend an off the floor should try to capture.

Commodity

Long Term
Trend

Intermediate
Trend

Corn

4 cents

2 cents

Wheat

5 cents

2 1/2 cents

Oats

3 cents

1 cent

Soybeans

10 cents

5 cents

Bean Meal

$5

$2.50

Bean Oil

50 points

30 points

The Benefits of the Point and Figure Method

The benefits of the Point and Figure Method are many. Not only is method easy to construct, the time involved is actually less than is required for a standard chart. By using the point and figure method, traders are able to instantly identify support and resistance levels, using breakouts of these levels as points of entry.

X

RESISTANCE

X

O

X

X

X

O

X

O

X

O

X

O

X

X

X

O

X

O

X

O

X

O

X

X

O

X

O

X

O

X

O

X

X

O

X

O

X

O

X

X

O

O

O

X

SUPPORT

The ease with which one can identify SUPPORT and RESISTANCE coupled with the fact that the Trend of the Market can always be identified using the Point and Figure Method are its two main benefits. Experience teaches us that most commodity traders lose money! Some of this is due to the fact that most commodity traders do not have a set plan in place for stop loss placement, and as such they tend to ride losers much to long. Using the Point and Figure Method, the trader can easily identify levels of support and resistance, and use those as stop loss points, identifying their risk with in reason.

Though Using the Point and Figure does not guarantee that the trader will be able to identify trends and make profitable trades, this method does instill some discipline into trading, and gives a basic premise to base decisions upon, which is something that many traders are lacking in their own trading.

The discipline the Point and Figure Method instills is key to long term profits in commodity trading. The basic premise of the Point and Figure Method encourages traders to follow the three main caveats to successful trading:

    1. Trade with the Trend
    2. Maximize Winners
    3. Cut Losing Positions

Though using the Point and Figure Method does not guarantee success in your speculative endeavors, it should help by instilling discipline into your trading. The largest drawback to the Point and Figure Method is that it does not identify Extremes, historic price tendencies, or account for crowd psychology. These pitfalls manifest themselves in "false break-outs". As with any type of trend following system, this will be a problem. However, by using the Point and Figure Method in conjunction with other forms of analysis, and solid money management, one can spot opportunities when the "odds" favor a move in a certain direction and take advantage of them.

Conclusion- A Picture is Worth a Thousand Words

The true beauty of the Point and Figure Method is that conveys the importance of price so the speculator, be he traders or hedger, can clearly identify where prices have been, as well as the current trend of the market, allowing him/her to make assessments of the probable future direction. Like any method, it has its pitfalls. But, unlike so many of the recent fad methods promoting ease of use, this one stands on a long history of use by professional traders.

The patterns derived by the Point and Figure Method are easily identifiable, with very little subjectivity involved. Due to this fact, anyone familiar with the Method can reach the same conclusion, with out counts, shifting cycles, divergences, and other revisions and modifications prevalent in many other forms of analysis. With support and resistance clearly laid out, the practitioner of the Point and Figure Method can always asses the risk involved in a trade (where to place the stop loss), as well as the trend of the market. It is the simplicity involved in this method, as well as the fact that it presents such a clear picture of trade, that accounts for its wide spread use by professional traders for the last century!

 

THE DATA CONTAINED HERE IN ARE BELIEVED TO BE RELIABLE BUT CANNOT BE GUARANTEED AS TO RELIABILITY, ACCURACY, OR COMPLETENESS; AND, AS SUCH ARE SUBJECT TO CHANGE WITHOUT NOTICE.  CFEA WILL NOT BE RESPONSIBLE FOR ANYTHING, WHICH MAY RESULT FROM RELIANCE ON THIS DATA OR THE OPINIONS EXPRESSED HERE IN.

DISCLOSURE OF RISK: THE RISK OF LOSS IN TRADING FUTURES AND OPTIONS CAN BE SUBSTANTIAL; THEREFORE, ONLY GENUINE RISK FUNDS SHOULD BE USED. FUTURES AND OPTIONS MAY NOT BE SUITABLE INVESTMENTS FOR ALL INDIVIDUALS, AND INDIVIDUALS SHOULD CAREFULLY CONSIDER THEIR FINANCIAL CONDITION IN DECIDING WHETHER TO TRADE. OPTION TRADERS SHOULD BE AWARE THAT THE EXERCISE OF A LONG OPTION WOULD RESULT IN A FUTURES POSITION.

HYPOTHETICAL PERFORMANCE RESULTS HAVE MANY INHERENT LIMITATIONS, SOME OF WHICH ARE DESCRIBED BELOW. 

NO REPRESENTATION IS BEING MADE THAT ANY ACCOUNT WILL, OR IS LIKELY TO, ACHIEVE PROFITS OR LOSSES SIMILAR TO THOSE SHOWN. IN FACT, THERE ARE FREQUENTLY SHARP DIFFERENCES BETWEEN HYPOTHETICAL PERFORMANCE RESULTS AND THE ACTUAL RESULTS SUBSEQUENTLY ACHIEVED BY ANY PARTICULAR TRADING PROGRAM. 

ONE OF THE LIMITATIONS OF HYPOTHETICAL PERFORMANCE RESULTS IS THAT THEY ARE GENERALLY PREPARED WITH THE BENEFIT OF HINDSIGHT. IN ADDITION, HYPOTHETICAL TRADING DOES NOT INVOLVE FINANCIAL RISK, AND NO HYPOTHETICAL TRADING RECORD CAN COMPLETELY ACCOUNT FOR THE IMPACT OF FINANCIAL RISK IN ACTUAL TRADING. FOR EXAMPLE, THE ABILITY TO WITHSTAND LOSSES OR TO ADHERE TO A PARTICULAR TRADING PROGRAM, IN SPITE OF TRADING LOSSES, ARE MATERIAL POINTS WHICH CAN ALSO ADVERSELY AFFECT ACTUAL TRADING RESULTS. THERE ARE NUMEROUS OTHER FACTORS RELATED TO THE MARKETS, IN GENERAL, OR TO THE IMPLEMENTATION OF ANY SPECIFIC TRADING PROGRAM WHICH CANNOT BE FULLY ACCOUNTED FOR IN THE PREPARATION OF HYPOTHETICAL PERFORMANCE RESULTS AND ALL OF WHICH CAN ADVERSELY AFFECT ACTUAL TRADING RESULTS.